Opinion

November 18, 2026

Whopper of the Week: RFK Jr.’s Doublespeak on Food Safety

THIS WEEK'S WHOPPER:

RFK JR.'S DOUBLESPEAK ON FOOD SAFETY 

“We cannot reverse America’s chronic disease epidemic without transforming our food system. These historic actions bring greater transparency to what’s in our food and stronger science to federal nutrition policy”  --  Robert F. Kennedy Jr., August 10, 2026
 

 

SUMMARY

Secretary Kennedy’s official food policy announcement, published in August 2026, promised to increase food system transparency, but he was not transparent himself. His reforms are a whopper because Kennedy is proposing to end one loophole while opening an even larger one. The Threshold of Regulation (TOR) expansion will create a new way for food additives and ingredients to directly enter the food supply without a formal Food and Drug Administration (FDA) review.

While Kennedy says that he is ending the voluntary notification system for new ingredients that are Generally Recognized as Safe (GRAS), he is not telling the public about the parallel rule, inserted quietly, which expands TOR exemptions. The TOR changes will increase rather than decrease food safety risks, with critics suggesting the TOR expansion could undermine any gains from limiting the GRAS rule.
 

WHY ITS A WHOPPER

Food safety regulation in the U.S. is very complicated, with many different, competing rules. GRAS is currently a voluntary check on new chemicals entering the U.S. food supply. Manufacturers are expected to follow accepted safety standards for food but can legally self-determine if their food products are safe, without independent scientific review. Additionally, TOR has applied to substances that indirectly come in contact with food. For example, new food packaging can be used if it’s shown not to be carcinogenic and dietary concentrations remain below 0.5 parts per billion.

As The Guardian first reported, when the Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) announced a proposed rule that would make it mandatory for manufacturers to submit GRAS notifications about new ingredients, HHS also included a provision to expand the TOR exemption to allow additives and ingredients directly into food. This expansion will allow companies to bypass formal FDA food additive review and GRAS notification requirements, countering the positive change Secretary Kennedy touted.

Scientists already consider many TOR exemption levels to be unsafe, especially for children. There are a host of chemicals known to cause harm at doses below 0.5 parts per billion limit which are not classified as carcinogenic, including perchlorate, certain phthalates, bisphenols, PFAS “forever chemicals” and flame retardants. Especially troubling, the TOR exemptions do not require manufacturers to submit the same level of safety data as required for GRAS submissions even though TOR exemptions can apply to ingredients containing PFAS or perchlorate, commonly known as “rocket fuel chemical.”

So even before the proposed expansion, scientists had questioned current TOR exemptions. Chemicals in packaging can migrate into food. In 2017, FDA scientists published a study demonstrating there were significant increases in perchlorate in food sampled from 2008 to 2012 compared to food from 2003 to 2006. What changed between the two timeframes? In 2005, FDA allowed perchlorate to be added as an anti-static agent to plastic packaging for dry food with no free fat or oil, including dry rice cereal for infants. 

In 2018 the Environmental Defense Fund (EDF) and other organizations challenged FDA’s 2005 decision to allow perchlorate in dry food plastic packaging and food handling equipment for cereal ingredients. According to EDF scientists, perchlorate in food affects children’s brains by disrupting thyroid hormone levels, which can lead to lowered IQ, loss of hearing and speech, and motor skill deficits. Cereal, a product commonly eaten by infants and children, can actually harm rather than support their health when packaged in perchlorate-enhanced grain bags. Unfortunately, in 2022, the court ruled that the FDA did not need to consider the effect of cumulative exposures when granting this TOR exemption. 

Current TOR exemptions apply only to food contact materials like packaging. Kennedy is proposing that any new ingredient used in food could qualify for a TOR exemption. The TOR expansion’s real danger is the unknown cumulative effect of these exempted chemicals on health. 
 

WHY IT MATTERS

Health advocates say the FDA’s proposed TOR expansion represents a major victory for the food industry at the expense of public health and endangers our food supply. The TOR expansion will allow chemicals to be added directly to products consumed daily without any labeling to inform the public. 

Once a new substance enters the food supply, it is extremely difficult to identify its potential risks. According to Consumer Reports, since TOR does not even require ingredient identification, “the FDA would be virtually unable to identify these substances, rendering any evaluation of cumulative risk almost impossible.” Some new ingredients may lead to injury rather quickly, for example liver damage caused by the ingredient tara flour in 2022, while long term health risks may require years of accumulation before any disease risks are identified, such as links between trans fatty acids and increased cardiovascular risk. 

To date there are only 144 TOR exemptions. But, potentially, hundreds of new products could enter our food system without any safety assessment. We would be much better served with a proactive clearance system that requires the evaluation of all new chemicals in foods and a mechanism to deny their use if determined they were harmful.

There is still time to voice your opposition to this egregious rule change. The FDA's public comment period is open through December 9, 2026 under “Docket FDA-2025-N-3262” in the Federal Register. Use this link to submit your comment: https://www.regulations.gov/docket

 

Contributors to this post are: Mary K. Canales, R.N, Ph.D., Aurora Horstkamp, M.D., David Goldberg, M.D., Bruce Mirken, Benedicte Callan, Ph.D.
 

Whopper of the Week